Services We Provide

Custom Cakes

We thrive in creating completely unique cakes just for YOU! We make cakes for every event! Contact us for all your cake needs.


Individually portioned with the perfect ratio of icing to cake. Yeah… cupcakes: when you don’t want to share.


Named after some of our favorite pinups! Bettie, Marilyn, Ginger. Who wouldn’t want a bite? Some of the BMB’s most popular treats!


Do the Truffle Shuffle! Chocolate gold. Flavored with anything from the traditional chocolate to our favorite booze and everything in between.

Juniper’s Cake Pops

Juniper is the daughter of Michelle. At 3 she started baking with her Mom and by the time she was 5, she debuted her cake pops at the market.

Farmers’ Market

Michelle finds it super important to participate in the local farmers’ markets! Keep track of where BMB is frequenting on the blog!

I would recommend Shelly’s cupcakes to anyone.

I am writing to let you know about the wonderful cupcakes Shelly Pierce made for my son’s baby shower. With only three days notice, she was able to make enough delicious cupcakes for everyone who was in attendance, with a couple left to spare. She offered a variety of flavors and was open to any specific requests I may have to their presentation, but I chose to go with the classic chocolate and vanilla; they accented the blue, brown, and white decorations. Once I decided on flavors and colors, she was able to use her skills and did a fabulous job! Independently she was able to create the perfect color and decoration, which accented the baby shower decor perfectly.

I would recommend Shelly’s cupcakes to anyone. Her professionalism and dependability are strong assets one can depend on when planning a special event. In addition, don’t forget the yummy product she delivers, both beautiful and delicious, and the highlight of any occasion!

Thank you, Kimberli S.

They were delicious! I’ll admit, I had to taste one of each kind.

Michelle Pierce provided her services for my daughter’s bridal shower in March. She baked seven dozen cupcakes in three different flavors and beautifully decorated them four different ways. The matched the colors and the theme of the wedding. Shelly also delivered them and displayed them beautifully for the shower. My daughter Lindsay was very pleased and I recieved many compliments on the cupcakes from the guests. They were delicious! I’ll admit, I had to taste one of each kind. My only regret was already asking a co-worker to do the wedding cake. It would have been nice to have Shelly do the wedding instead.

Thanks again! Jan C.

My Works

TMNT Cake (Hand sculpted Turtles!)

Nightmare Before Christmas (Sally) Cake

Snoopy Cake (Gum Paste Snoopy and Woodstock)

Purple Girly Cake

Gum Paste Flower Details

Fall Wedding Cake with Edible Leaves


Wedding Cake

Skylander Cake

Nightmare Before Christmas (Jack) Cake

Hellraiser Birthday Cake (all fondant custom sculpting)

Hellraiser Cake

Wedding Cupcake Table

Poky Puppy Display

Chocolate, Peanut Butter, and Pretzels

Bits of Glass Cupcakes

Mom's Day Cupcakes

Knitter's Mitten Details

Knitter's Cakes

'It's a Girl' Cupcake Display

Girl Baby Shower Details

Valentines Day Rose Cupcakes

Braaaains... for the BG Zombie Walk for Charity

Pretty Pink Boe

Skulls, Roses, and Hearts

Pink Boe

Strawberry Cupcake with Vanilla Italian Butter Cream

Baby Cakes Piping

Strawberry Swirl Cupcakes

Half a Zombie (Walking Dead Tribute)

Zombie Grave

Zombie Lady

Sally Gum Paste Model


Poky Puppy


Juniper's Cake Pops

Farmers' Market Display

Bettie's and Marilyn's

Farmers' Market


Pretty Packaging!

Truffle Assortment

Melt Man (or Salad Fingers) Cakepop

Our Team

Michelle (Shelly) Pierce

The Sole Proprietor of Black Magic Bakery: loves baking with her daughter, family, and rock 'n' roll! Things you may not know about her: She met her husband Digger when she auditioned to sing for their hard rock band, Nothing Safe. She also graduated from culinary school with honors!

Mallie Mae Grim

Mallie Mae is considered the BMB's Design Partner. It doesn't hurt that she's also one of Shelly's best friends! Mallie is currently going to college to become a composition teacher (writing is kind of her thing.) She loves tea, tiny pastries, poetry, and her awesomely giant cat, Brookie Lan.


Digger Pierce

Digger is Michelle's husband and occasionally BMB's Artist! Digger is a tattoo artist at Broad Wing Tattoo in Bowling Green, Ohio. If ever there is an intricate paint or air brush design that needs to be handled by a steady hand, Digger has been known to swoop in and help a bakery out!

Juniper Pierce

Juniper is the daughter of Digger and Michelle and has been a helping hand in the kitchen since she was 3! Juni loves Ballet, Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles, singing, and making cake pops with mom! Cool fact about Juniper: Lzzy Hale of Halestorm posted a video of Juni singing 'Rock Show' on her twitter!

Our Skills

Custom Cakes

Here at BMB we work hard to make sure our customers are happy! We pride ourselves on being able to design an amazingly rad cake for our equally amazing customers.

A little Pop Culture, anyone?

The BMB specializes in  unique cake designs! We’ve done everything from horror to comic book motif. We LOVE all things different and enjoy the challenge!

Fondant and Gum Paste = Baker’s Clay!

Want a mini selfie on your cake? No worries, no molds needed! We specialize in sculpting!











Follow Us


©2014 Black Magic Bakery. All Rights Reserved.